Machiavellianism: What it is, how to recognize and cope with Machiavellians

What is Machiavellianism?

Machiavellianism is a personality trait that denotes cunningness, the ability to be manipulative, and a drive to use whatever means necessary to gain power. Machiavellianism is one of the traits that forms the Dark Triad, along with narcissism and psychopathy. Based on current datum, it tends to decrease in age and is more prevalent in men than in women.

Using strategies to gain power and prestige

The personality trait was described by Machiavelli in his book “The Prince”, written in the 16th century. Machiavelli wrote the book to describe how leaders could use strategies to gain power and prestige. The personality trait of Machiavellianism has also been described in contemporary studies of leadership (Judge et al., 2009); within the leadership arena, individuals who score high on Machiavellianism tend to be cunning, manipulative and will use whatever means necessary to gain political power.

Machiavellian leaders maximise their personal power

Machiavelli encourages leaders to lie, manipulate and use coercive persuasion to serve their own needs. Individuals who score high on Machiavellianism are not necessarily in a position of formal power but engage in techniques to boost their own self-worth. They are skilled in impression management techniques with a natural talent for influencing others with the main aim of maximizing opportunities for their own personal power.

Moral and ethical standards do not matter to Machiavellians 

Machiavellians have little regard in adhering to moral or ethical standards. They focus on money, power and competition and place little emphasis on community building, self-care, and family commitment; they aim to win at any cost (Spielberger & Butcher, 2013). Within the workplace, Machiavellians engage in flattery, deceit, coercion and can be abusive (Calhoon, 1969).

How do we recognize Machiavellianism?

There are several ways to recognize machiavellians. From a scientific perspective, there is an inventory (Mach-IV) that was developed by Christie and Geis (1970) and is still viewed as the primary way to assess Machiavellianism.

The Mach-IV inventory helps assess Machiavellian traits

The Mach IV test consists of twenty questions and uses self-report. Those with a high score on the scale are more likely to be deceitful and lack empathy (Spielberger & Butcher, 2013). The Mach IV test includes items such as

• “The Best way to handle people is to tell them what they want to hear”,
• “It is wise to flatter important people,” and
• “the biggest difference between most criminals and other people is that the criminals are stupid enough to get caught.”

Individuals who respond in the affirmative are more likely to be a Machiavellian.

There are four ways to identify a Machiavellian         

Empirical research suggests several ways to spot a Machiavellian in the workplace.

1. Machiavellians perform well in work environments where the rules are ambiguous; for example, places where there is an emphasis on creativity can be ambiguous because the nature of innovation and creativity is chaotic leading to ambiguity on what is required. There is also evidence that Machiavellians do less well in company that are rules-based and they frequently ignore the set procedures of the institution (Grover & Enz, 2005).
2. Machiavellians are unable to show the full range of emotions and can appear detached from situations. In fact, when distressing events occur whereby most individuals would display negative affect, Machiavellians gain pleasure from watching negative events unfold (Amorim, Sousa & Chamorro-Premuzic, 2009).
3. Initially, Machiavellians will be charismatic and friendly. They will use both soft and hard tactics to obtain their objectives such as using self-disclosure; however, they will also attempt to make someone feel guilty (Jonason, Slomski & Partyka, 2012).
4. Machiavellians perform well in competitive environments and initially, colleagues will find Machiavellians friendly because they use soft tactics to gain commitment (Jonason et al., 2012). However, over time, Machiavellians tend to lose favour as colleagues detect the inauthenticity of their actions.

Machiavellians use certain strategic behaviors

In an HRM article that focused on the dark triad traits of narcissism, Machiavellianism and psychopathy, Schyns and colleagues identified negative strategic behaviors that Machiavellians use (Schyns, Wisse, & Sanders, 2019).

1. Unlike narcissists, Machiavellians do not have to be the center of attention and are satisfied as being puppeteers, who pull the strings.
2. They try to minimize the influence of others and withhold knowledge with colleagues. They use manipulation to reach their goals while scheming for personal benefit. They tend to compete rather than be cooperative (Schyns et al, 2019).
3. Within the workplace they will also entice coworkers to engage in risky behaviors and will try to seduce their coworkers or supervisors into romantic relationships to suit their own ends (Schyns et al., 2019).

How to cope with Machiavellians

There are several ways to deal with Machiavellians and certain behaviors to avoid. Based on the empirical literature on the behaviours and characteristics of Machiavellians (e.g., Furnham, Richards, & Paulhus, 2013), there are several ways to deal with them:

Engage in self-care

Machiavellians can be destructive and can prey on the good nature of colleagues through using a mixture of soft and hard tactics such as seduction and bullying. This kind of behaviour can have a deleterious effect on psychological well-being. Consequently, it is important to set boundaries and to consider speaking with a clinician who can help in reducing anxiety and stress from dealing with a Machiavellian.

Accept your limitations

Because Machiavellianism is a personality trait (Furnham et al., 2013), it is important to accept that you cannot change the person. Personality traits are relatively stable across situations. When Machiavellians find opportunities to exploit others, they will do so if the environment allows it. Consequently, the environment is important to consider because it can increase a Machiavellian’s destructive behaviour. It is best if you limit your interactions with a Machiavellian.

Engage in self-compassion

Machiavellians tend to prey on those who are kind and considerate. They will appeal to this type of person to gain empathy when divulging their life issues. This can lead to exploitation and you might find yourself in a vulnerable position. It is important not to engage in derogation of yourself but to engage in self-compassion and to reach out to supportive others.

Rely on trusted colleagues

It is important to talk with colleagues, whom you trust so you can break away from the grip of the Machiavellian. A colleague can also provide impartial advice because they are not part of the toxic relationship and can help you to break away from the situation. A trusted colleague will point out the facts and can help deal with the emotional toil of the toxic relationship.

Engage in a mastery mindset

Machiavellians want to win so it is important that you also focus on your work goals and not be blind-sided by their manipulative strategies. The best way to do this is to engage in mastery mindset strategies whereby you strive to do well and reach your objectives rather than try to beat the Machiavellian.

Focus on a Machiavellian’s actions

Machiavellians will try to deceive you with promises to win your trust. This is a common strategy that they use to meet their personal ends. It is important to rely on your instinct and focus on what Machiavellians do rather than what they say. Machiavellians engage in behaviours that demonstrate their unethical standards and many of these behaviours are easy to identify (Den Hartog & Belschak, 2012).

Focus on work-based conversations

When conversing with a Machiavellian, it is important to discuss work-based topics. When you discuss your personal life with a Machiavellian, they might use this information to their own personal advantage. It is important to remember that they are not a trusted confidante.

Do not try to outplay them

It is important that you don’t engage in the same strategies as a Machiavellian. If you do so, they will be more effortful in their strategies. It is best to use ethical strategies.

Combatting Machiavellianism by being authentic

The most important advice is to remember your core values and to adhere to principles and set objectives that meet these values. Focus on displaying your positive personality traits in the workplace and strengthen your own self-worth. These positive traits will help you succeed in the workplace. The behaviour exhibited by Machiavellians does not negate your self-worth.